Is Neutrogena Sunscreen Safe?

The Short Answer

The safety of Neutrogena sunscreen depends entirely on which bottle you buy. Their classic chemical formulas—like the wildly popular Ultra Sheer Dry-Touch—are loaded with hormone-disrupting chemicals and score a dismal 7 or 8 out of 10 on the EWG toxicity scale.

However, Neutrogena's mineral lines are incredibly safe. Their Pure & Free Baby and Sheer Zinc formulas use 100% mineral active ingredients, earning top safety ratings from environmental watchdogs without absorbing into your bloodstream.

Why This Matters

Neutrogena is one of the most trusted names in the drugstore aisle, but their chemical sunscreen track record is deeply concerning. In 2021, parent company Johnson & Johnson had to recall several Neutrogena aerosol sunscreens after independent testing found elevated levels of benzene, a known human carcinogen.

While the benzene contamination was fixed, the baseline ingredients in their chemical formulas remain problematic. They rely heavily on outdated chemical filters that are known to absorb into the body and disrupt hormones. Chemical Sunscreen Bloodstream

If you're grabbing a bottle of Beach Defense or Ultra Sheer on your way to the pool, you are exposing yourself to chemical concentrations that are strictly restricted in Europe. You don't have to abandon the brand, but you absolutely have to read the labels. Mineral Vs Chemical Safer

What's Actually In Neutrogena Sunscreen

Neutrogena's active ingredients vary wildly depending on whether you choose their chemical or mineral lines.

• Homosalate (Up to 15%) — A chemical UV filter that functions as an endocrine disruptor. Neutrogena uses it in concentrations up to 15%, which is far beyond the EU's strict 7.3% safety limit. Is Homosalate Endocrine Disruptor
• Avobenzone — A notoriously unstable chemical UV filter that degrades quickly in sunlight and can trigger skin allergies. Is Avobenzone Safe
• Octocrylene — Used to stabilize avobenzone, but it can degrade into benzophenone, a potential carcinogen.
• Oxybenzone — The most notorious hormone-disrupting sunscreen chemical. While Neutrogena is actively phasing it out, it still lingers in some older formulas on store shelves. Is Oxybenzone Safe
• Zinc Oxide (21.6%) — The sole active ingredient in their Sheer Zinc and Pure & Free Baby lines. It provides excellent, broad-spectrum protection without absorbing into your bloodstream. Is Zinc Oxide Safe

What to Look For

Green Flags:

• Active Ingredient: Zinc Oxide — If zinc is the only active ingredient listed, the formula is safe, stable, and highly effective.
• The "Pure & Free" or "Sheer Zinc" Label — These are Neutrogena's dedicated mineral lines that consistently score high marks for safety.
• Lotion Formats — Lotions eliminate the risk of inhaling dangerous propellants or airborne chemicals.

Red Flags:

• Aerosol Sprays — Spray sunscreens pose an inhalation risk and have a troubling history of benzene contamination.
• The "Ultra Sheer" or "Beach Defense" Labels — These are Neutrogena's flagship chemical lines, which rely on a cocktail of hormone-disrupting filters.
• Anything ending in "-one" or "-ate" — Active ingredients like avobenzone, oxybenzone, and homosalate are clear signs you're holding a chemical formula. Sunscreen Ingredients Avoid

The Best Options

If you want to stick with Neutrogena, skip the chemical aerosols and head straight for their mineral lotions.

The Bottom Line

1. Ditch the aerosol sprays. They carry unnecessary inhalation risks and rely on the worst chemical filters.

2. Read the active ingredients. If you see homosalate, octocrylene, or avobenzone, put it back on the shelf.

3. Choose the Zinc lines. Neutrogena's Pure & Free Baby and Sheer Zinc lotions are affordable, accessible, and genuinely safe. Best Sunscreen Babies

FAQ

Did Neutrogena sunscreen have a recall?

Yes, in 2021. Parent company Johnson & Johnson recalled specific lots of Neutrogena aerosol spray sunscreens (including Beach Defense and Ultra Sheer) after testing revealed dangerous levels of the cancer-causing chemical benzene.

Is Neutrogena Ultra Sheer sunscreen safe?

We do not recommend it. While Neutrogena has removed oxybenzone from most Ultra Sheer formulas, they still rely heavily on homosalate and octocrylene, which score poorly for endocrine disruption.

Does Neutrogena sunscreen have benzene in it?

Not intentionally. Benzene is a manufacturing contaminant, not an ingredient, and the company has since reformulated to fix the issue. However, aerosol chemical sprays remain the most vulnerable to this type of chemical contamination.

---

References (6)

1. 1. cruisecritic.com
2. 2. reddit.com
3. 3. kitchenstewardship.com
4. 4. todaysparent.com
5. 5. neutrogena.com
6. 6. neutrogena.com