Coconut Milk vs Almond Milk — What's the Difference?

The Short Answer

Almond milk and coconut milk are fundamentally different beverages disguised in similar cartons. If you want a low-calorie everyday milk, almond is the winner; if you need rich texture and healthy fats, choose coconut.

Unsweetened almond milk is remarkably light, clocking in at just 30-40 calories and 1-3 grams of fat per cup. It's the perfect neutral base for daily smoothies, coffee, and cereal.

Unsweetened carton coconut milk is significantly richer, containing 45-80 calories and up to 5 grams of saturated fat. Neither milk provides meaningful protein naturally, so your choice comes down entirely to fat content and flavor preference.

Why This Matters

Choosing the wrong plant milk can completely derail your nutritional goals. Pouring heavy coconut milk into your daily protein shake can inadvertently add hundreds of calories over a week. On the flip side, using thin almond milk in a curry will leave you with a watery, disappointing texture.

The dairy-free aisle is also a minefield of ultra-processed additives. Most commercial plant milks are 98% water thickened with cheap industrial gums. Understanding how to read these labels is crucial if you want actual nutrition rather than just a milky-looking liquid. Is Plant Milk Healthy

You also need to understand the difference between healthy and unhealthy fats. The saturated fat in coconut milk behaves differently in your body than the fat in a cheeseburger. The MCTs (medium-chain triglycerides) in coconuts are metabolized quickly for energy, making coconut milk a staple for keto dieters and metabolic health.

What's Actually In These Milks

Whether you choose almond or coconut, the ingredient lists on commercial cartons look remarkably similar. Most mainstream brands use the exact same base formula of water, nuts, and thickeners.

• Filtered Water — The primary ingredient in almost all commercial plant milks.
• Nut or Coconut Base — Premium brands use up to 20% almonds or coconut cream, while budget brands use as little as 2%. Cleanest Almond Milk
• Gums & Emulsifiers — Additives like gellan gum and sunflower lecithin used to fake a creamy texture. Gums Plant Milk Bad
• Carrageenan — An outdated inflammatory thickener that still lurks in a few legacy products. Is Carrageenan Safe
• Cane Sugar — Found in anything labeled "Original," adding up to 10 grams of empty carbohydrates per cup. Least Sugar Plant Milk

What to Look For

Green Flags:

• Short ingredient lists — Water, almonds or coconut, and salt should be the only ingredients.
• Organic certification — Crucial for avoiding heavy pesticide residues.
• High nut content — Brands that boast about using more nuts per serving naturally achieve better creaminess.

Red Flags:

• "Original" flavor labels — This is industry code for "sweetened with cane sugar."
• Long lists of gums — If a milk needs three different thickeners, it doesn't contain enough actual nuts.
• Added vegetable oils — Cheap brands add sunflower or canola oil to fake a richer texture.

The Best Options

When shopping for either milk, prioritize brands that don't rely on industrial thickeners. Here are the cleanest options on the market right now.

The Bottom Line

1. Choose almond for low-calorie versatility. It's best for daily coffees, cereal, and smoothies where you want a neutral base.

2. Choose coconut for texture and keto macros. The MCT fats make it ideal for rich desserts, cooking, and metabolic energy.

3. Always buy unsweetened. You can always add your own high-quality sweetener at home if needed, avoiding the cheap cane sugar used in factories.

FAQ

Can I substitute almond milk for coconut milk in recipes?

It depends entirely on the recipe. You can easily swap them in cereal or smoothies, but using almond milk instead of canned coconut milk in a curry will result in a watery, flavorless disaster.

Does almond milk or coconut milk have more calcium?

Neither naturally contains much calcium. However, most commercial brands of both almond and coconut milk are fortified to match or exceed the calcium content of cow's milk. Plant Vs Cow Milk Nutrition

Is canned coconut milk the same as carton coconut milk?

No, they are completely different products. Canned coconut milk is designed for cooking and contains a massive amount of fat, while carton coconut milk is heavily diluted with water for daily drinking.

---

References (13)

1. 1. simplegreensmoothies.com
2. 2. oreateai.com
3. 3. simplegreensmoothies.com
4. 4. oliveyouwhole.com
5. 5. tastewise.io
6. 6. theguardian.com
7. 7. navikmills.com
8. 8. econutrena.com
9. 9. cozymeal.com
10. 10. fooddatascrape.com
11. 11. alibaba.com
12. 12. sporked.com
13. 13. harriswoolfalmonds.com