Is By-Product Meal Bad in Dog Food?

The Short Answer

The verdict is mixed: named by-products are great, but generic by-products are a massive red flag. You don't need to avoid all by-product meals.

If the label identifies the exact animal—like "chicken by-product meal"—you are looking at a highly concentrated protein source that provides essential vitamins. Because the moisture is removed, these meals contain nearly 300% more protein per ounce than fresh meat.

However, if the label just says "meat by-product meal" or "animal by-product meal," put the bag down. Generic labels allow manufacturers to use whatever leftover animal parts are cheapest that day. This leads to inconsistent nutrition and potential digestive distress for your dog.

Why This Matters

Boutique pet food marketing has spent millions training consumers to view all by-products as toxic waste. This is a marketing tactic designed to sell expensive food, not a scientific fact. In reality, wolves and wild dogs always eat the internal organs of their prey first because they are the most nutrient-dense parts of the animal.

The real issue comes down to quality control and ingredient transparency. A high-quality by-product meal is packed with liver, kidneys, and heart—organs rich in taurine and iron. But a low-quality, feed-grade by-product meal can include poorly handled leftovers from anonymous rendering plants. Is Meat Meal Bad

This is why veterinary nutritionists care more about the precise nutrient profile than the raw ingredient list. Your dog's body absorbs amino acids and vitamins, not ingredient names. Still, knowing how to read the label protects your dog from bottom-barrel processing. What Should Be First Ingredient Dog Food

What's Actually In By-Product Meal

• Organ Meats — Livers, kidneys, and spleens are natural superfoods. They provide critical vitamins and taurine that standard muscle meat lacks.
• Clean Bones and Cartilage — These are ground down during the rendering process. They serve as an excellent natural source of calcium, phosphorus, and glucosamine.
• Rendered Tissue — The parts are cooked at extremely high temperatures to remove water and kill bacteria. This creates a sterile, highly concentrated powder that is roughly 65% pure protein.

What to Look For

Green Flags:

• Named Species — Look for specific identifiers like "chicken by-product meal" or "pork by-product meal." Specific names prove the manufacturer is controlling their sourcing.
• Veterinary Backing — Brands that meet WSAVA (World Small Animal Veterinary Association) guidelines use by-products safely. These companies run rigorous feeding trials to prove their meals are highly digestible. What Dog Food Do Vets Recommend

Red Flags:

• Unnamed Sources — Avoid "animal by-product meal," "meat by-product meal," or "poultry by-product meal." If they won't name the animal, they are hiding a cheap, inconsistent ingredient. Dog Food Ingredients To Avoid
• Lack of Whole Proteins — While by-product meals are nutritious, they shouldn't be the only thing in the bowl. Ideally, a whole meat or standard named meat meal should also appear high on the ingredient list.

The Best Options

Not all companies process their by-products with the same care. The most reliable brands operate their own facilities and rigorously test their supply chain.

The Bottom Line

1. Check the species. If the animal is clearly named on the label, the by-product meal is generally safe and nutritious.

2. Don't fear organ meat. Livers, hearts, and kidneys are natural superfoods that support your dog's long-term health.

3. Run from generic labels. Any ingredient that just says "meat" or "animal" is a glaring red flag for poor quality control.

FAQ

Are hooves, hair, and feathers allowed in by-product meal?

No, the AAFCO strictly bans hair, horns, teeth, hooves, and feathers from standard by-product meals. While myths claim these go into dog food, it is a legal violation of feed control standards to include them intentionally.

Is fresh whole meat better than by-product meal?

Not necessarily, because fresh meat is 70% water and only 18% protein. When the food is cooked into kibble, that water evaporates, meaning a by-product meal actually provides significantly more concentrated protein by weight. What Should Be First Ingredient Dog Food

Why do expensive brands brag about having "no by-products"?

It is largely a marketing gimmick designed to appeal to human food sensibilities. Many premium brands substitute by-products with heavy amounts of peas and legumes, which are actually linked to heart disease. Does Grain Free Cause Heart Disease

---

References (14)

1. 1. duxburyanimalhospital.com
2. 2. kristinajohansen.com
3. 3. nutritionrvn.com
4. 4. bullymax.com
5. 5. aafco.org
6. 6. stellaandchewys.com
7. 7. campfiretreats.com
8. 8. aafco.org
9. 9. dogfoodadvisor.com
10. 10. purina.com
11. 11. vcahospitals.com
12. 12. nih.gov
13. 13. drruthroberts.com
14. 14. corey.ca