The Short Answer
Most commercial dog treats are safe to eat but dangerous to feed regularly. Think of them as candy bars for your dog. While they won't cause immediate death (unless they are tainted rawhide or jerky from China), they are biologically inappropriate.
The biggest immediate risks are contamination and choking. In 2024 and 2025 alone, we saw recalls for Salmonella in pig ears and metal shards in major dry food brands. The long-term risk is obesity and cancer. Popular soft chews rely on sugar for taste and BHA/BHT for shelf lifeāingredients that have no place in a dog's diet.
The verdict: Treat them with Caution. Swap processed biscuits for single-ingredient proteins or fresh vegetables.
Why This Matters
Obesity is killing dogs.
Latest data shows 60% of dogs in the U.S. are overweight or obese. Excess weight strips years off your dog's life and causes joint pain, diabetes, and heart issues. Treats are the "hidden calories" that most owners ignore. A single large biscuit can contain as many calories as a human donut relative to a dog's size.
The "China Problem" isn't over.
In January 2025, the FDA updated its import alerts regarding poultry jerky from China due to antibiotic and antiviral residues. While the massive Fanconi syndrome outbreaks of the 2010s have subsided, imported jerky remains a gamble. Always check the "Made in..." labelāmanufacturers often hide this in small print. Are Dog Treats From China Safe
Preservatives are toxic.
To keep semi-moist treats soft and shelf-stable for years, brands use heavy-duty chemicals. BHA (Butylated Hydroxyanisole) is a known carcinogen in animal studies, yet it is still legal in U.S. pet food. If a treat stays soft in the bag for two years, ask yourself why bacteria won't eat it.
What's Actually In Popular Treats
Commercial treats like Pup-Peroni and Milk-Bone are chemically engineered to be addictive. Here is what you are actually buying:
- Sugar / Corn Syrup ā Often the 3rd or 4th ingredient. It causes inflammation, dental decay, and obesity. Dogs do not need added sugar.
- Propylene Glycol ā Used in "soft" treats to keep them moist. It is chemically related to antifreeze (ethylene glycol). While "safe" for dogs (but toxic to cats), it is an unnecessary chemical additive.
- BHA / BHT ā Synthetic preservatives linked to cancer and hormone disruption. Banned in human food in many countries, but standard in American dog treats. Dog Treat Ingredients To Avoid
- Artificial Colors (Red 40, Yellow 5) ā purely for your benefit. Dogs are colorblind to red; the dye is there to make the "bacon" look real to you. These dyes are linked to hyperactivity and allergies.
What to Look For
Green Flags:
- Single Ingredient ā The ingredient list has one word (e.g., "Beef Liver," "Sweet Potato").
- Freeze-Dried or Dehydrated ā Processes that preserve nutrients without chemicals.
- Sourced in USA/NZ/Canada ā Stricter safety standards than many other regions.
Red Flags:
- "Meat" or "Animal" Meal ā Generic proteins often rendered from sick or euthanized animals. Is Meat Meal Bad
- Sugar / Molasses / Syrup ā Any sweetener is a hard no.
- Made in China ā Specifically for chicken or duck jerky products. Are Dog Treats From China Safe
- Rawhide ā Often a byproduct of the leather industry, washed in bleach and glued together. Is Rawhide Safe For Dogs
The Best Options
The best treat is food. Single-ingredient proteins or fresh vegetables offer high rewards with zero toxicity.
| Brand / Type | Product | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Generic | Freeze-Dried Liver | ā | High value, single ingredient, nutrient-dense. |
| Kitchen | Green Beans / Carrots | ā | Low calorie, crunchy, zero processing. |
| Greenies | Dental Chews | ā ļø | Acceptable for teeth, but contains wheat fillers & glycerin. |
| Milk-Bone | Original Biscuits | š« | Wheat-heavy junk food with BHA preservatives. |
| Pup-Peroni | Lean Beef Flavor | š« | High sugar, propylene glycol, and artificial dyes. |
| Rawhide | Any Brand | š« | Choking hazard; chemical processing residue. |
The Bottom Line
1. Ditch the "Grocery Store" aisle. If it's colorful, soft, and cheap, it's likely junk.
2. Read the label. If you see BHA, BHT, Sugar, or Red 40, put it back.
3. Feed fresh. A baby carrot or a cube of cheese is often healthier (and cheaper) than a processed biscuit.
FAQ
Are Milk-Bones safe for dogs?
Technically safe, but not healthy. They are essentially empty calories made of wheat and preservatives like BHA. Occasional use is fine for most dogs, but they are nutritionally poor and contribute to obesity. Is Milk Bone Safe
Is rawhide dangerous?
Yes. Rawhide is a choking hazard that can cause intestinal blockages. It is also a byproduct of the leather industry, often treated with bleach and formaldehyde. Switch to bully sticks or collagen chews instead. Is Rawhide Dangerous
Can I give my dog "human" food as treats?
Yes, and you should. Blueberries, apples (no seeds), carrots, and green beans are excellent, low-calorie treats. Avoid grapes, raisins, onions, and chocolate, which are toxic.
References (25)
- 1. thestreet.com
- 2. fda.gov
- 3. petfoodindustry.com
- 4. ukpetfood.org
- 5. petrecalls.com
- 6. reddit.com
- 7. fda.gov
- 8. askavet.com
- 9. dogfoodadvisor.com
- 10. globalpetindustry.com
- 11. doggygrub.com.au
- 12. goodrx.com
- 13. forma.pet
- 14. thebalancedcanine.co.uk
- 15. lordjameson.com
- 16. pierrepark.com
- 17. cornell.edu
- 18. truthaboutpetfood.com
- 19. canadapetcare.com
- 20. pupford.com
- 21. wearethecure.org
- 22. kwikpets.com
- 23. quora.com
- 24. walmart.com
- 25. skipperspetproducts.com