Is Drunk Elephant Moisturizer Clean?

The Short Answer

Drunk Elephant is the brand that defined "Clean at Sephora," but for the strict non-toxic crowd, it earns a Caution verdict.

While they famously ban the "Suspicious 6" (essential oils, drying alcohols, silicones, chemical sunscreens, fragrances/dyes, SLS), their definition of clean is "clinical," not "natural." They freely use synthetic emulsifiers (PEGs) and preservatives like Phenoxyethanol, which many crunchy consumers avoid due to contamination risks and skin sensitivity.

The biggest red flag is recent: In November 2024, Drunk Elephant issued a voluntary recall for arguably their two most famous moisturizers—Protini and Lala Retro—due to ingredient mix-ups that led to bacterial and yeast contamination. When a "clean" brand fails to keep actual bugs out of your face cream, it’s a major trust issue.

Why This Matters

Safety protocols failed.

The 2024 recall wasn't just a labeling error. Specific batches of Lala Retro lacked preservatives entirely, leading to the growth of Candida parapsilosis (a yeast). Protini batches were found to contain Klebsiella and Enterobacter bacteria. Putting contaminated product on your face—especially near eyes or on broken skin—is a serious health risk.

"Clinical" doesn't mean "Non-Toxic."

Drunk Elephant prioritizes "biocompatibility" over natural ingredients. This means they use lab-made synthetics like Polysorbate 60 and Ceteareth-20. These are ethoxylated ingredients (PEGs), which can be contaminated with 1,4-dioxane (a likely carcinogen) during manufacturing. What Face Cream Ingredients To Avoid

Preservatives are a double-edged sword.

The brand uses Phenoxyethanol and Chlorphenesin. While better than parabens, Phenoxyethanol is restricted in infant products in Europe and can be an irritant/allergen for some. Ironically, the lack of these preservatives in the recalled batches caused the contamination, proving that if you use water-based formulas, you must preserve them correctly—something natural brands often struggle to balance.

What's Actually In Their Moisturizers

Here is the breakdown of their "Big Three" creams.

Protini Polypeptide Cream (Gel-Cream for Anti-Aging)

• Signal Peptide Complex — Good. 9 plant-derived peptides that plump skin.
• Pygmy Waterlily — Good. Antioxidant and soothing source.
• Phenoxyethanol & Chlorphenesin — Caution. Synthetic preservatives.
• Polysorbate 20 & 60 — Caution. Ethoxylated emulsifiers (PEGs) with contamination concerns.

Lala Retro Whipped Cream (Rich Cream for Dryness)

• African Oil Blend — Good. Marula, mongongo, baobab, and melon oils. Great for barrier repair.
• Ceramides (AP, EOP, NP) — Good. Skin-identical lipids that restore the barrier.
• Ceteareth-20 — Caution. A high-concern PEG derivative that enhances penetration (allowing other chemicals deeper into skin).
• Crosspolymers — Acceptable. Synthetic texture enhancers that give it that "whipped" feel.

Bora Barrier Repair Cream (Heavy Occlusive for Redness)

• Zinc & Copper Gluconates — Good. Excellent for calming redness and healing.
• 6-Butterlipid Complex — Good. Deeply moisturizing for compromised barriers.
• Glucosyl Ceramide — Good. Helps skin produce its own ceramides.
• Synthetics — Caution. Heavy reliance on synthetic thickeners to stabilize the rich formula.

What to Look For

Green Flags:

• No Fragrance — Zero scent means zero hidden phthalates. Is Fragrance In Moisturizer Bad
• No Essential Oils — Great for reactive/sensitive skin types.
• pH Balanced — Formulated to support the acid mantle (usually pH 4.0-5.5).

Red Flags:

• Recall History — Check your lot numbers immediately if you own these.
• Ethoxylated Ingredients — Look for "PEG-", "Polysorbate", or "-eth" in the name.
• Synthetic Preservatives — Not suitable for those avoiding all synthetics.

The Best Options

If you want the "active" benefits of Drunk Elephant without the synthetics or safety concerns, try these alternatives.

The Bottom Line

1. Check your jars. If you have Protini, Lala Retro, or Beste No. 9 bought in late 2024, check the Drunk Elephant website for recall lot numbers immediately.

2. Know your "clean." If you just want fragrance-free and effective, DE is fine (post-recall). If you want non-toxic (no PEGs/synthetics), this brand is not for you.

3. Don't overpay for synthetics. You can find clean ceramide and peptide moisturizers from brands like Cocokind or Honest Beauty for half the price and fewer toxins.

FAQ

Is Drunk Elephant safe for pregnancy?

Generally yes. They avoid retinols (in the moisturizers) and salicylic acid is usually low concentration. However, Phenoxyethanol is something some pregnant women choose to avoid. Always consult your OB.

Does Drunk Elephant use parabens?

No. They are 100% paraben-free. They use Phenoxyethanol, Chlorphenesin, and Sodium Benzoate instead.

Is Drunk Elephant 100% natural?

No. They are explicitly "biocompatible," not natural. They believe synthetic ingredients can be safer than natural ones (like essential oils) if they are less irritating. Crunchy researchers often disagree regarding the safety of the synthetics they choose.

---

References (18)

1. 1. ewg.org
2. 2. incidecoder.com
3. 3. cosmeticsbusiness.com
4. 4. ulta.com
5. 5. cosmeticsbusiness.com
6. 6. glimmergoddess.com
7. 7. skinsort.com
8. 8. marieclaire.com
9. 9. newbeauty.com
10. 10. incidecoder.com
11. 11. beautymatter.com
12. 12. drunkelephant.com
13. 13. aveseena.com
14. 14. reddit.com
15. 15. topclassactions.com
16. 16. happi.com
17. 17. thefashionlaw.com
18. 18. wordpress.com