Bar Soap vs Body Wash — Which Is Better?

The Short Answer

If you want to save money and the planet, bar soap is the winner. It costs pennies per wash, has a minimal carbon footprint, and eliminates plastic waste. The idea that it's "unhygienic" is a complete myth.

However, if you struggle with eczema, chronicity dry skin, or a compromised skin barrier, body wash (or a syndet bar) is objectively better. Traditional bar soap has a high pH (around 9-10) that can strip your skin's natural oils. Body wash is formulated to be closer to your skin's natural pH (5.5), making it gentler.

Why This Matters

Your shower habit is a plastic disaster.

Most body wash comes in virgin plastic bottles that are rarely recycled. Because liquid soap is up to 80% water, we are burning fossil fuels to ship heavy water around the globe. Switching to bar soap is the single easiest way to reduce your bathroom's environmental impact.

Your skin barrier is under attack.

While bars are eco-friendly, they can be harsh. The "squeaky clean" feeling from traditional soap is actually your acid mantle being stripped away. If you switch to bar soap, you must look for superfatted options or "syndet" bars (synthetic detergents) to avoid turning your skin into sandpaper. Is Body Wash Bad

What's Actually In Them

Body Wash:

• Water (Aqua) — usually the first ingredient, making it heavy to ship and requiring preservatives to prevent mold.
• Surfactants — often sulfates like SLS or SLES that create foam but can irritate skin. Is Sulfate In Body Wash Bad
• Preservatives — liquid formulas are breeding grounds for bacteria, so they require strong preservatives like parabens or formaldehyde releasers. Is Fragrance In Body Wash Bad

Bar Soap:

• Saponified Oils — fats (olive, coconut, palm) reacted with lye. Once the process is done, no lye remains.
• Glycerin — a natural byproduct of soap making that draws moisture to the skin. (Note: commercial brands often remove this to sell separately in lotions).
• Hardening Agents — ingredients like sodium lactate that keep the bar from turning to mush.

What to Look For

Green Flags:

• "Superfatted" (for bars) — means extra oil was added after saponification to moisturize.
• "Syndet" (for sensitive skin) — synthetic detergent bars (like Dove) that have a neutral pH.
• Biodegradable packaging — paper wrappers or naked bars.

Red Flags:

• "Antibacterial" — usually contains triclosan or similar chemicals that are unnecessary and harmful to the microbiome. Is Antibacterial Hand Soap Necessary
• Microbeads — plastic exfoliating beads that pollute oceans (largely banned, but watch for alternatives).
• Fragrance/Parfum — a catch-all term for thousands of undisclosed chemicals. Is Fragrance In Body Wash Bad

The Best Options

If you have normal skin, prioritize the environment. If you have sensitive skin, prioritize pH balance.

The Bottom Line

1. Switch to bar soap if you have normal or oily skin. It is the most sustainable and cost-effective choice.

2. Use a "syndet" bar (like Dove or CeraVe bar) if you have dry skin but want to reduce plastic. You get the gentle pH of a body wash with the eco-benefits of a bar.

3. Stick to creamy body wash only if you have severe skin conditions that require specific medicinal ingredients or extreme hydration. Safest Body Wash

FAQ

Is bar soap unhygienic?

No. This is a marketing myth created to sell body wash. Studies dating back to 1988 prove that while bacteria can live on the "slime" of a soap bar, it does not transfer to your skin during washing. Your loofah actually harbors far more dangerous bacteria than a bar of soap ever will.

Can I use bar soap on my face?

Proceed with caution. Most body bars have a pH of 9-10, while your face is a delicate 5.5. Using body soap on your face can destroy your acid mantle, leading to acne and sensitivity. Only use bars specifically formulated for the face (facial bars). Is Face Wash Stripping Skin

Why does bar soap leave soap scum?

Soap scum forms when the fatty acids in real soap react with the minerals in hard water (calcium and magnesium). Body wash doesn't do this because it's a detergent, not a soap. If you have hard water, a syndet bar or body wash will rinse cleaner.

---

References (17)

1. 1. safecosmetics.org
2. 2. taobao.com
3. 3. skipper.org
4. 4. hawaiianbathbody.com
5. 5. the-clean-chemist.com
6. 6. waterfallglensoap.com
7. 7. spritzwellness.com
8. 8. aurelderma.com
9. 9. thewrinklyelephant.com
10. 10. butterandlye.com
11. 11. jergens.com
12. 12. grumpyolegoat.com
13. 13. oliverthom.com.au
14. 14. nih.gov
15. 15. borealisderm.com
16. 16. mrhygiene.shop
17. 17. smocskincare.com