Is Italian Pasta Safer Than American?

The Short Answer

If you've ever gone to Italy, eaten your weight in pasta, and felt surprisingly fine afterwards, you aren't imagining things. Italian pasta really is different—but only if you buy the right kind.

The difference boils down to one chemical: Glyphosate. In 2016, Italy banned the use of glyphosate (the active ingredient in Roundup) for "pre-harvest desiccation." This means Italian farmers cannot spray their wheat with weedkiller right before harvest to dry it out. In the US and Canada, this practice is standard operating procedure for conventional wheat, leading to significant herbicide residue in the finished product.

However, there is a trap. Most "Italian" brands sold in the US (like Barilla) are actually made in factories in Iowa or New York using American wheat. Even some brands made in Italy (like De Cecco) import wheat from Arizona or Canada to mix with their local flour. To be safe, you must look for the label "100% Italian Wheat" (Grano 100% Italiano) or "Certified Organic."

Why This Matters

The "Dessication" Dirty Secret

In the US and Canada, farmers often spray wheat crops with glyphosate days before harvest. It's not for weed control—it's to kill the crop so it dries out faster and evenly. This is called "desiccation." Because this happens right before the grain is collected, the chemical doesn't have time to break down, resulting in residues up to 100x higher than if it were sprayed earlier in the season. Italy strictly forbids this.

The Gluten Difference

It’s not just chemicals. American pasta is typically made from "strong" gluten wheat designed for high-speed industrial extruders. It’s dried at extremely high temperatures (up to 200°F+) to speed up production. This denatures the proteins, making them harder for your enzymes to break down. Traditional Italian pasta is slow-dried at low temperatures, preserving the protein structure and making it more digestible. Is Gluten Bad For You

The Labeling Loophole

"Made in Italy" on a box only means the processing happened in Italy. It does not tell you where the wheat came from. Italy is the world's largest pasta producer, but they don't grow enough Durum wheat to meet demand. They import massive amounts from Canada and the US. Unless the package explicitly says "100% Italian Wheat," you might be eating Canadian wheat that was shipped to Naples, processed, and shipped back to you—glyphosate included.

What's Actually In Your Pasta?

• Durum Wheat Semolina — The hard wheat used for pasta. Look for "Organic" or "100% Italian" to avoid desiccation chemicals.
• Glyphosate — The "hidden ingredient." A 2022 study by Saldo found glyphosate traces in 7 out of 18 conventional pasta brands tested. Glyphosate In Flour
• Mycotoxins (DON) — Mold toxins that can contaminate wheat stored in damp conditions. While Italian wheat is cleaner for pesticides, it can sometimes be higher in mycotoxins if not stored properly.
• Enrichment Vitamins — If you see "Niacin, Iron, Thiamine" on the label, it's a sign of refined American flour. Traditional high-quality Italian pasta often has just one ingredient: Durum Wheat Semolina.

What to Look For

Green Flags:

• "100% Italian Wheat" — The gold standard. Legally ensures no pre-harvest glyphosate.
• "Trafilata al Bronzo" — Bronze-cut. Leaves a rough texture that holds sauce better and indicates a slower, higher-quality production process.
• "Slow Dried" — Or "Lenta Essiccazione." Easier to digest.
• "Gragnano IGP" — A protected certification for pasta made in Gragnano, Italy, with strict quality controls.

Red Flags:

• "Made in USA" — Usually found on the bottom of the box in small print (e.g., Barilla Blue Box).
• "Enriched Macaroni Product" — Dead giveaway of highly processed industrial flour.
• Chickpea / Lentil Pasta — Surprisingly, brands like Banza have tested for very high levels of glyphosate because chickpeas are heavily desiccated crops.
• Smooth, Shiny Noodles — Indicates Teflon extrusion and high-heat drying (plastic-like texture, harder to digest).

The Best Options

Most grocery stores carry at least one "real" Italian option. You just have to read the fine print.

The Bottom Line

1. Check the Country of Manufacturing. If it says "Distributed by Barilla America, Northbrook, IL" and doesn't say "Product of Italy," it's American wheat. Put it back.

2. Hunt for "100% Italian Wheat". This is your insurance policy against glyphosate. Brands like La Molisana print this proudly on the front.

3. Go Organic for American Brands. If you buy American-made pasta (like 365 or Trader Joe's), it must be certified organic to ensure no desiccation chemicals were used.

4. Avoid "Healthy" Chickpea Pasta. Unless it is certified organic, legume pastas are some of the dirtiest items in the pantry regarding herbicides.

FAQ

Why does pasta in Italy not make me bloat?

It's likely the lack of pesticides and preservatives. Italian laws ban glyphosate desiccation and many additives allowed in the US. Also, Italian pasta is slow-dried, keeping the gluten protein structure intact, which makes it easier for your body to break down compared to the high-heat industrial drying used in the US.

Is Barilla pasta healthy?

The Barilla Blue Box sold in the US is a processed industrial product made in Iowa with conventional wheat. It is not "unhealthy" per se, but it carries a higher risk of glyphosate residue than authentic Italian brands. Barilla's Organic or Al Bronzo lines are significantly better choices.

Is De Cecco better than Barilla?

Yes. De Cecco is always made in Italy (Fara San Martino), uses bronze dies for better texture, and slow-dries their pasta. However, they do import some wheat from the US and elsewhere, so they are not a "100% Italian Wheat" brand, but their testing standards are generally higher than US-made Barilla.

---

References (10)

1. 1. bonafurtuna.com
2. 2. wusf.org
3. 3. non-gmoreport.com
4. 4. vicofoodbox.com
5. 5. tastingtable.com
6. 6. packagingstrategies.com
7. 7. nowtoronto.com
8. 8. professionalpasta.it
9. 9. foodtimes.eu
10. 10. caputos.com