The Short Answer
Most candles do not use pure essential oils. The vast majorityāincluding fancy "natural" soy brandsāuse synthetic fragrance oils or "natural fragrance" isolates. These are engineered to smell stronger and last longer, often using phthalates (hormone disruptors) and solvents that release VOCs when burned.
To ensure your candle has no synthetic fragrance, you must look for the words "100% Essential Oil Scented" explicitly on the label.
If you see the word "Fragrance," "Parfum," or "Natural Fragrance" without an asterisk explaining exactly what it is, it is synthetic or heavily processed. The safest options are Fontana Candle Co (MADE SAFE certified) and Primally Pure, which use only whole essential oils and clean waxes.
Why This Matters
"Fragrance" is a black box. Under US law, fragrance formulas are trade secrets. A single word on the label can hide hundreds of chemicals, including phthalates, which are known endocrine disruptors linked to reproductive harm. Are Air Fresheners Toxic
Burning synthetics creates indoor smog. When synthetic fragrance oils are heated, they release Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs) like formaldehyde and benzene. This essentially creates second-hand smoke in your living room, contributing to asthma, headaches, and respiratory irritation. Do Air Fresheners Cause Asthma
Natural doesn't always mean safe. Even "natural fragrance" oils can be processed with petrochemical solvents. Whole essential oils are the only way to ensure you are smelling a plant, not a chemistry experiment. Are Scented Candles Bad
What's Actually In Conventional Candles
Most candles are a cocktail of petroleum and perfume.
- Paraffin Wax ā A byproduct of oil refining. When burned, it releases toluene and benzene (carcinogens found in car exhaust). Is Paraffin Wax Toxic
- Synthetic Fragrance ā Man-made chemicals designed to mimic nature. They are often "boosted" with phthalates to make the scent linger longer.
- Wick Cores ā While lead wicks are banned, many wicks still use zinc or tin cores to stand up straight, which release metal particulate matter into the air.
- Dyes ā purely aesthetic chemicals that add unnecessary toxins to the burn.
What to Look For
Green Flags:
- "100% Essential Oils" ā Look for this exact phrase.
- Beeswax or Tallow ā The cleanest burning waxes that undergo minimal processing. Are Beeswax Candles Safer
- Coconut Wax ā A good plant-based alternative to soy (which is often GMO and pesticide-heavy).
- Wood Wicks ā Usually untreated and burn cleanly (plus they crackle).
- MADE SAFE Certification ā The gold standard for non-toxic verification.
Red Flags:
- "Fragrance Oil" ā Code for synthetic.
- "Nature Identical" ā Lab-created to look like a natural molecule, but isn't.
- "Soy Blend" ā Usually means 51% soy and 49% paraffin.
- "Aromatherapy Scent" ā Marketing fluff. Unless it lists specific oils, it's fake.
- Bright Colors ā Artificial dyes are unnecessary pollution.
The Best Options
There are very few brands that strictly use 100% essential oils and zero synthetic compounds. These are the ones we trust.
| Brand | Product | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fontana Candle Co | Essential Oil Candles | ā | MADE SAFE certified. Beeswax/Coconut blend. Zero synthetics. |
| Primally Pure | Beeswax Candles | ā | Wildcrafted essential oils and pure beeswax. Very clean. |
| Natural Sloth | Beeswax Candles | ā | MADE SAFE certified. Simple ingredients. |
| Slow North | Soy Candles | ā ļø | Good essential oil scents, but uses soy wax (less clean than beeswax). |
| Grow Fragrance | Plant-Based Candle | ā ļø | 100% plant extracts (transparent), but uses isolates, not just whole oils. |
| Bath & Body Works | Any Candle | š« | Paraffin blend, synthetic fragrance, dyes. Avoid. |
The Bottom Line
1. Read the ingredient list, not the vibe. "Aromatherapy" and "Natural" mean nothing. Look for "100% Essential Oils."
2. Expect a lighter scent. Real plants don't smell as strong as factory chemicals. An essential oil candle won't scent your entire house like a chemical bombāand that's a good thing for your lungs.
3. Switch to Beeswax. It is the only wax that doesn't require heavy chemical processing (bleaching/hydrogenation) to exist. Are Beeswax Candles Safer
FAQ
Why do essential oil candles smell less strong?
Synthetic candles use phthalates and chemical boosters to artificially extend the "throw" (how far the scent travels). Essential oils are volatile and burn off faster. A lighter scent is the trade-off for not inhaling hormone disruptors.
Is "Natural Fragrance" the same as Essential Oils?
No. "Natural Fragrance" is often comprised of isolatesāspecific molecules extracted from plants in a labārather than the whole oil. While better than full synthetics, they are more processed and less transparent than 100% essential oils.
Are soy candles safe?
It depends. Soy wax is better than paraffin, but most "soy candles" are actually soy-paraffin blends (brands only need 51% soy to use the label). Also, most soy crops are GMO and heavily sprayed with pesticides. Beeswax or Coconut wax are generally cleaner choices. Are Soy Candles Safer
References (16)
- 1. shiftinggaia.com
- 2. shivoracandles.ca
- 3. orbasics.com
- 4. lgcandle.com
- 5. organicbeautylover.com
- 6. integritybotanicals.com
- 7. fontanacandlecompany.com
- 8. thezoereport.com
- 9. forbes.com
- 10. madesafe.org
- 11. notedcandles.com
- 12. thenewknew.com
- 13. nalancaster.com
- 14. seawitchbotanicals.com
- 15. thegoodtrade.com
- 16. solideogloriacandlecompany.com