What's the Healthiest Pancake Mix?

The Short Answer

If you want the cleanest ingredients, Simple Mills Almond Flour Mix is the winner. It uses nutrient-dense almond flour, organic coconut sugar, and contains zero gums, bleached flours, or inflammatory oils. It tastes like real food because it is real food.

For a low-carb or keto option, Birch Benders Paleo is your best bet. It uses cassava and coconut flour sweetened with monk fruit, keeping sugar near zero.

Kodiak Cakes is the "gym bro" favorite. It's an acceptable choice if prioritizing protein (14g per serving) is your main goal, but be aware it uses conventional wheat and oats, which puts it at risk for glyphosate contamination.

Avoid legacy brands like Bisquick, Pearl Milling Company (formerly Aunt Jemima), and Krusteaz. These are essentially stripped carbs mixed with aluminum-based leaveners and soybean oil.

Why This Matters

Pancakes are often dismissed as "dessert for breakfast," but the mix you choose determines whether you're eating a nutrient-dense meal or a chemical cocktail.

The biggest hidden issue in pancake mix is Sodium Aluminum Phosphate. This chemical leavening agent creates that fluffy rise in "just add water" mixes. While FDA-approved, it is a source of dietary aluminum, which can accumulate in the body and has been linked to neurological concerns in high doses. You are literally eating metal to make your pancakes fluffy.

Then there is the Glyphosate problem. Most conventional pancake mixes are made from non-organic wheat and oats. These crops are often desiccated (dried out) with glyphosate (Roundup) right before harvest. Testing has found glyphosate residues in 95% of oat-based products, making organic certification vital for any grain-based mix. Glyphosate In Oatmeal

What's Actually In Pancake Mix

Here is the breakdown of what you are actually pouring onto the griddle.

• Bleached Enriched Flour: Wheat flour stripped of its bran and germ (fiber and nutrients), then bleached with chemicals like benzoyl peroxide. It spikes blood sugar rapidly. Is Oatmeal Healthy
• Sodium Aluminum Phosphate: A chemical leavener used in "complete" mixes because it reacts slowly with heat. It is a source of aluminum.
• Partially Hydrogenated Oils: While banned in many forms, fully hydrogenated or interesterified soybean oils still appear in mixes like Bisquick to add fat without spoiling. Seed Oils
• Dextrose / Sugar: Added sugar is often the second or third ingredient. A "breakfast" serving can easily contain as much sugar as a candy bar before you even add the syrup. Is Maple Syrup Healthy

What to Look For

Green Flags:

• Almond, Coconut, or Cassava Flour: Nutrient-dense bases that provide healthy fats and fiber. Is Simple Mills Pancake Clean
• Organic Certification: Crucial for wheat or oat-based mixes to avoid glyphosate.
• Natural Sweeteners: Coconut sugar, monk fruit, or just real cane sugar (low on the list).
• Cream of Tartar / Baking Soda: The clean alternative to aluminum leaveners.

Red Flags:

• "Complete" or "Just Add Water": Usually implies powdered milk and chemical leaveners are present.
• Sodium Aluminum Phosphate: The aluminum warning sign.
• Soybean or Canola Oil: Inflammatory seed oils used as cheap fat sources.
• Artificial Flavors: Common in "fun" flavors (blueberry, chocolate chip, confetti).

The Best Options

Here is how the top brands stack up based on ingredient purity and nutrition.

The Bottom Line

1. Swap the Flour: Choose mixes based on almond or cassava flour (like Simple Mills) for better blood sugar stability and nutrient density.

2. Go Organic for Grains: If you want wheat or oat pancakes, buy organic. This is your only shield against glyphosate.

3. Check the Leavener: Flip the box and scan for "Aluminum." If you see it, put it back.

4. DIY is Best: You can make the healthiest mix at home: 1 cup oat flour, 1 egg, 1/2 cup milk, 1 tsp baking powder. Pancake Mix Vs Homemade

FAQ

Is Kodiak Cakes actually healthy?

It depends. If your priority is maximizing protein intake, it's a convenient vehicle for 14g of protein. However, it is not organic, meaning the wheat and oats likely contain glyphosate residues. It also contains added cane sugar. Simple Mills Protein Mix is a cleaner alternative. Is Kodiak Cakes Clean

What is the safest flour for pancakes?

Almond flour or organic oat flour. Almond flour offers healthy fats and protein with a low glycemic impact. Organic oat flour provides fiber without the pesticide load of conventional oats. Cleanest Oatmeal

Why do some mixes say "do not eat raw batter"?

This isn't just about raw eggs. Conventional flour is a raw agricultural product that can contain E. coli or Salmonella. "Heat-treated" flour is safer, but most box mixes use standard flour that requires cooking to kill bacteria.

Is Bisquick really that bad?

Yes. Bisquick contains DATEM (an emulsifier), monoglycerides, soybean oil, and sodium aluminum phosphate. It is a highly processed food product designed for shelf life, not health. Whats In Bisquick

---

References (11)

1. 1. eatthis.com
2. 2. thekitchn.com
3. 3. mashed.com
4. 4. netrition.com
5. 5. betterhealthmarket.com
6. 6. glutenfreepalace.com
7. 7. foodsweeteners.com
8. 8. bakerpedia.com
9. 9. meowmeix.com
10. 10. marianos.com
11. 11. ewg.org