The Short Answer
Dave's Killer Bread is Acceptable, but proceed with caution if you are watching your sugar or inflammation levels.
It is significantly better than conventional brands like Wonder or Nature's Own because it is Certified Organic, non-GMO, and free from artificial preservatives and dough conditioners like Is Datem Safe|DATEM. However, it relies on organic canola oil for moisture and organic cane sugar for flavor.
The "21 Whole Grains" loaf has 5 grams of added sugar per slice. Two slices of toast equal the sugar content of a glazed donut.
Why This Matters
Bread shouldn't be dessert.
Most store-bought breads are chemical concoctions disguised as food. We've covered this in Is Store Bread Bad, where we detailed how manufacturers use emulsifiers to fake freshness. Dave's skips the worst additives, which is a huge win.
But Dave's solves the texture problem with sugar and oil.
Real bread requires three things: flour, water, salt. Maybe yeast or starter. When you add oils and sweeteners, you are making a shelf-stable cake. For the health-conscious consumer, the high Omega-6 content in canola oil and the blood sugar spike from cane sugar are valid concerns.
What's Actually In Dave's Killer Bread
Here is the breakdown of their most popular loaf, 21 Whole Grains and Seeds:
- Organic Whole Wheat — The base is solid. Certified organic means no synthetic pesticides.
- Organic Cane Sugar — The third ingredient. This is why it tastes so good to children. It's not just for yeast activation; it's for flavor.
- Organic Expeller-Pressed Canola Oil — A controversial fat. While "expeller-pressed" is better than chemically extracted, it is still a seed oil high in Omega-6 fats. Oils In Crackers
- Organic Wheat Gluten — Isolated plant protein added to make the bread chewy and fluffy. It's processed, but safe for non-celiacs.
- Organic Cultured Wheat Flour — A natural preservative that replaces calcium propionate. This is a Green Flag.
What to Look For
Green Flags:
- Certified Organic: Guarantees no glyphosate desiccation (spraying wheat to dry it out).
- No Dough Conditioners: No azodicarbonamide or DATEM found here. What Are Dough Conditioners
- Nutrient Density: High fiber and protein counts per slice compared to standard bread.
Red Flags:
- Sugar Content: 5g per slice is excessive. Look for the "Powerseed" loaf (1g sugar) instead.
- Canola Oil: Even organic canola can be inflammatory for some.
- Glyphosate Residue: Recent 2026 testing found trace levels (~11 ppb). This is likely due to drift and is 10x lower than conventional brands, but it's not zero.
The Best Options
If you love the brand, choose carefully. Not all "Killer" breads are created equal.
| Product | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Powerseed | ✅ Recommended | Sweetened with fruit juice (1g sugar), decent protein. |
| Sprouted Whole Grains | ✅ Recommended | Better digestibility, lower glycemic impact. Is Sprouted Bread Healthier |
| 21 Whole Grains | ⚠️ Acceptable | High sugar (5g/slice). Treat it like a treat. |
| White Bread Done Right | ⚠️ Acceptable | It's still white flour, even if unbleached. Low nutrient density. |
The Bottom Line
1. Read the label for sugar. Don't assume "whole grain" means low sugar. If it has >3g per slice, it's a sweet bread.
2. Swap for Powerseed. It’s the cleanest loaf in their lineup because it ditches the cane sugar.
3. Consider the alternatives. If you want truly clean bread, look for Ezekiel (flourless, sugar-free) or local Sourdough (fermented). Daves Vs Ezekiel
FAQ
Is Dave's Killer Bread actually healthy?
It depends on your definition. Compared to Wonder Bread? Yes. Compared to homemade sourdough or Ezekiel? No. The high sugar content and canola oil make it a "transition food" rather than a health staple.
Does Dave's Killer Bread contain glyphosate?
Trace amounts. 2026 tests showed levels around 10-11 ppb. This is extremely low compared to conventional brands (often 100+ ppb) and is considered safe by standards, but it highlights that widespread contamination affects even organic supply chains.
Is Dave's Killer Bread inflammatory?
Potentially. It contains added sugar and canola oil, both of which can be inflammatory triggers. If you are strictly avoiding seed oils, this bread is not for you.
Why is there wheat gluten in the ingredients?
Dave's adds organic vital wheat gluten to create that soft, chewy texture Americans love. Whole grain bread naturally crumbles; added gluten acts as the "glue" to hold it together. Whole Wheat Vs Whole Grain
References (8)
- 1. healthline.com
- 2. believebig.org
- 3. haggen.com
- 4. ewg.org
- 5. heinens.com
- 6. foodsco.net
- 7. pavilions.com
- 8. haggen.com