The Short Answer
Huggies is a better drugstore choice than Pampers, simply because every diaper they make is 100% fragrance-free. That alone eliminates a massive source of allergens and phthalates that plagues their main competitor.
However, Huggies is not a clean brand.
Most Huggies lines (especially Little Snugglers and Little Movers) are currently facing scrutiny due to class-action lawsuits alleging chemical burns from a proprietary surfactant called Ahcovel and a new "blue liner" material introduced in late 2024. Additionally, they still use ECF (Elemental Chlorine Free) bleaching, which means chlorine dioxide is used in processing, leaving potential for trace dioxins.
If you must buy Huggies, the Special Delivery line is the only one we consider "Acceptable." It avoids the controversial blue liner, uses more plant-based materials, and is significantly softer.
Why This Matters
The "Blue Liner" Burn Issues
In late 2024 and through 2025, parents began reporting severe, burn-like rashes on babies wearing Little Movers and Little Snugglers. Lawsuits allege this is linked to a formulation change involving a blue-dyed liner and higher levels of a chemical called Ahcovel. Is Diaper Cream Safe won't fix a chemical burn caused by the diaper itself.
Chlorine Bleaching (ECF vs. TCF)
Huggies uses Elemental Chlorine Free (ECF) pulp. This is better than old-school bleach, but it still uses chlorine derivatives. The gold standard for non-toxic diapers is Totally Chlorine Free (TCF), which ensures zero risk of dioxin contamination. Brands like Coterie and HealthyBaby are TCF. Huggies is not. Is There Dioxin In Diapers
Hidden Plastics & Glues
Even though they are fragrance-free, parents often complain that Huggies smell like "chemicals" or "glue" when wet. This is likely due to Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs) releasing from the petroleum-based plastics and adhesives used to hold the diaper together.
What's Actually In Huggies
Here is the breakdown of the materials found in standard Huggies (Little Snugglers / Little Movers):
- Wood Pulp (ECF) — The absorbent core. Bleached with chlorine dioxide, which is a "Caution" grade process. Is There Chlorine In Diapers
- Ahcovel (C12-14 Sec-Pareth-3) — A surfactant sprayed on the liner to help urine absorb quickly. This specific ingredient is the subject of lawsuits claiming it causes skin sloughing and burns.
- Polypropylene & Polyethylene — Standard petroleum-based plastics used for the liner and outer shell.
- Sodium Polyacrylate (SAP) — The absorbent gel balls. Generally considered safe, but petroleum-derived. Is Sap In Diapers Safe
- Blue Dye / Pigments — Used in the "blowout blocker" strip. The recent formulation change involving this blue dye correlates with the spike in burn reports.
- Elastic — Synthetic rubber (latex-free).
What to Look For
Green Flags:
- Fragrance-Free Policy — Huggies does not add masking scents, unlike Pampers.
- Special Delivery Line — Uses sugar-cane derived plastics and generally lacks the "blue liner" issues.
Red Flags:
- ECF Bleaching — Uses chlorine dioxide instead of being totally chlorine-free.
- "Blowout Blocker" (Blue Strip) — Currently linked to irritation complaints in Little Movers.
- Ahcovel — A chemical additive that isn't necessary in higher-quality diapers.
The Best Options
If you need a drugstore diaper, Huggies Special Delivery is the safest bet. If you can order online or shop at premium retailers, you can do much better.
| Brand | Product | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Coterie | The Diaper | ✅ | TCF, zero fragrance, huge absorption, no Ahcovel. Is Coterie Diapers Clean |
| Huggies | Special Delivery | ⚠️ | Plant-based shell, fragrance-free, but still ECF bleached. |
| Huggies | Little Snugglers | 🚫 | Contains Ahcovel; high volume of chemical burn reports. |
| Pampers | Swaddlers | 🚫 | Contains fragrance and lotion. Is Pampers Safe |
The Bottom Line
1. **Avoid Little Movers and *Little Snugglers*** if your baby has sensitive skin, due to the active lawsuits regarding chemical burns and the "blue liner."
2. **Buy *Special Delivery*** if you are loyal to the Huggies fit. They are significantly cleaner, softer, and don't seem to have the same burn issues as the standard line.
3. Choose TCF whenever possible. Brands like HealthyBaby or Coterie eliminate the chlorine concern entirely.
FAQ
Is Huggies better than Pampers?
Yes. Huggies is the safer choice because they are 100% fragrance-free. Pampers adds a "baby fresh" scent to almost all their diapers, which is a common allergen and potential source of phthalates. Pampers Vs Huggies Safety
What is the "Blue Liner" issue?
In 2024/2025, Huggies updated Little Movers with a blue "blowout blocker" strip. Since then, thousands of parents have reported sudden, severe rashes that look like chemical burns. A class-action lawsuit claims this is due to the new materials and the chemical Ahcovel.
Are Huggies chlorine-free?
No. They are "Elemental Chlorine Free" (ECF), which means they don't use elemental chlorine gas, but they do use chlorine dioxide. They are not "Totally Chlorine Free" (TCF).
Does Huggies use phthalates?
Huggies states they do not use phthalates. Because they are fragrance-free, they avoid the most common source of phthalates (fragrance fixatives). However, trace phthalates can sometimes be found in adhesives, though Huggies is generally cleaner than scented brands here.
References (19)
- 1. prnewswire.com
- 2. target.com
- 3. target.com
- 4. nonwovens-industry.com
- 5. farzanlaw.com
- 6. healthproductsforyou.com
- 7. samsclub.com
- 8. huggies.com
- 9. target.com
- 10. classaction.org
- 11. babygearlab.com
- 12. huggies.com
- 13. huggies.com
- 14. topclassactions.com
- 15. topclassactions.com
- 16. brainhealthfrombirth.com
- 17. walmart.com
- 18. diaperdabbler.com
- 19. walmart.com